What to Do Before You Sell a Diamond Ring to Get the Fairest Price

9th May 2025 – Daniel Ives

It’s normal to feel unsure about the next steps when you decide to sell a diamond ring. From gathering documentation to finding the right buyer, here’s how to make sure you’re fully prepared, and why working with Burlingtons Ltd. can make all the difference.

Emotional Preparation 

Understand Why You’re Selling

Your motivation for selling matters, so before diving into the practicalities, take a moment to reflect on your reasons. Understanding your “why” helps guide the rest of your journey, both emotionally and practically. For many, this step can even lead to closure. 

Being clear on your reason also helps you feel more in control. We’ve worked with clients selling for countless reasons, each valid, each unique. Whatever your story, we’re here to listen and to help you move forward with clarity and confidence.

Be Aware of Emotional vs. Market Value

It’s completely natural to have an emotional attachment to a diamond ring, especially if it carries family history or personal memories. However, it’s important to distinguish between how much the ring means to you and what it’s worth in the current market.

We understand this can be a difficult step. That’s why we offer a sensitive, respectful service that takes both the emotional and monetary value of your piece into account.

Item Preparation

Gather Documentation and Certificates

Having original documentation can make a significant difference in the valuation of your ring. Have the original box to hand if possible. Look for receipts, insurance appraisals, diamond grading certificates (such as GIA or IGI), and any other paperwork that helps verify the ring’s authenticity and history.

Even if you don’t have everything, don’t worry – we will still offer a thorough assessment. But any documents you do have can help support a higher valuation and faster sale.

Learn the 4 Cs and Other Key Features

Familiarise yourself with the four Cs: Carat, Cut, Colour, and Clarity. These are the main factors used to grade a diamond and assess its value. If the ring includes a designer mark or is set in high-quality metal like platinum or 18ct gold, those details also matter.

You don’t need to become an expert overnight, but having a basic understanding of what makes your ring valuable can help you feel more empowered throughout the process.

Clean the Ring and Prepare It for Presentation

A clean ring makes a better impression during valuations and when shared with potential buyers. You can gently clean it yourself with warm water, mild soap, and a soft toothbrush, or have it professionally cleaned for the best results.

Take Clear Photos If Needed

If you’re contacting a buyer remotely or sending images for a preliminary valuation, take high-quality, well-lit photos of the ring from multiple angles. Include close-ups of the diamond, the setting, and any hallmarks.

This helps experts like our own Daniel Ives make a more accurate initial assessment, saving time and ensuring you receive meaningful feedback.

Market Research and Valuation Options

Research Current Market Conditions

Like any luxury item, diamond ring values can fluctuate depending on trends, economic conditions, and demand. Take some time to explore recent prices for similar pieces online or through resale platforms, but remember, retail and resale prices differ significantly.

We base our valuations on real-time market insights and decades of experience, ensuring that your offer reflects both quality and demand.

Get a Professional Valuation

An accurate, professional valuation is essential before you commit to selling. Avoid estimates from general jewellers or online calculators, as these often lack the expertise needed for high-value items. Many calculators are also not up-to-date with current market conditions.

Our valuations are led by Daniel Ives, an expert with over 25 years of experience in the luxury jewellery industry. He will ensure you receive an informed, personal assessment without leaving your home.

Set Realistic Expectations

It’s helpful to keep in mind that second-hand diamond rings, no matter how beautiful, will rarely fetch their original retail price. Factors like wear, style, and whether the ring is from a branded designer all influence the resale value.

Choosing a Sales Path

Avoid Scams and Lowball Offers

Unfortunately, the second-hand jewellery market can attract dishonest buyers offering less than your ring’s true worth. Be cautious of offers that feel rushed or too good to be true, and avoid platforms that lack transparency or customer protection.

Decide Where to Sell

There are several routes you can take: auctions, pawnbrokers, online listings, or trusted private buyers. However, it’s important to note that each has their own advantages and disadvantages. For example, auctions are a well-known route with many options across the UK, but the process is often slow and can command high fees. 

We believe selling valuable items should be straightforward, respectful, and rewarding. That’s why we aim to offer an alternative to auctions, in which we provide a free, no-obligation, fully secure valuation in the comfort of your own home.

Take the Next Step and Sell a Diamond Ring

If you’re thinking about selling your diamond ring, we are here to make the process simple, personal, and stress-free. With decades of expertise and a reputation built on honesty and discretion, you can expect a personalised service with no hidden fees, no pressure, and no need to send your valuable item away. You’ll also get an instant payment if you choose to sell.

Start your journey with someone you can trust. Get in touch with Burlingtons Ltd. today and discover the value of your diamond ring with confidence.